Arohana Legal

Arohana Legal - Buisness Logo

Legal Documentation for Investors, PEs, and VCs in India

Blog on Legal Documentation for investors, PE, and VCs in Startups

I. Introduction

A. Importance of legal documentation for Investors in Startup Investments

Investing in startups is a high-risk, high-reward endeavor that requires meticulous attention to legal documentation. For investors, comprehensive and well-drafted legal documents serve as the foundation for safeguarding their interests, mitigating risks, and ensuring a smooth investment process. Legal documentation plays a pivotal role in establishing the rights, obligations, and expectations of all parties involved, thereby minimizing the potential for disputes and protecting the value of the investment.

In the context of startup investments, legal documents encompass a wide range of agreements, contracts, and disclosures. These include term sheets, share subscription agreements, shareholders’ agreements, intellectual property assignments, employment contracts, and compliance documentation. Each of these documents serves a specific purpose in defining the terms of the investment, outlining governance structures, and securing the interests of both investors and founders.

Robust legal documentation is particularly crucial in the early stages of a startup’s lifecycle when the company’s valuation is largely based on intangible assets such as intellectual property, business models, and growth potential. Investors rely on legal documents to ensure that their investment is secure and that the startup has a clear legal framework for operation and growth. Furthermore, legal documentation helps investors perform thorough due diligence, assessing potential risks and liabilities associated with the investment.

If you are an investor, PE, or VC looking to invest in startups, read our guide on investing in startups in India.

B. Overview of the Indian startup investment ecosystem

India has emerged as the third-largest startup ecosystem in the world, with over 1,17,254 DPIIT-recognized startups across various sectors. The Indian startup ecosystem has witnessed tremendous growth in recent years, driven by factors such as a large and growing consumer market, increasing digital adoption, a thriving talent pool, and supportive government policies.

The Indian government has played a significant role in fostering the growth of the startup ecosystem through initiatives such as Startup India, which provides benefits, incentives, and a conducive regulatory environment for startups. The government has also established a network of incubators and accelerators across the country to support early-stage startups.

In terms of investment, the Indian startup ecosystem has attracted significant capital from both domestic and international investors. In 2021 alone, Indian startups raised a record $42 billion in funding, with sectors such as e-commerce, fintech, enterprise tech, and edtech being the top recipients. The ecosystem boasts over 100 unicorns (startups valued at $1 billion or more), with a combined valuation of approximately $240 billion.

The investor landscape in India comprises a diverse mix of venture capital firms, angel investors, private equity funds, and corporate investors. Notable investors in the Indian startup ecosystem include Sequoia Capital, Accel Partners, Tiger Global Management, and SoftBank, among others. These investors bring not only capital but also strategic guidance, mentorship, and global networks to support the growth of startups.

However, understanding the legal and regulatory framework of startup investments in India can be complex. Investors must be well-versed with various laws and regulations, such as the Companies Act, 2013, the Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA), and sector-specific regulations. This underscores the importance of robust legal documentation and the guidance of experienced legal professionals to ensure compliance and protect the interests of all stakeholders in the investment process.

Read our blog to know more about legal documentation for startups in India.

II. Pre-Investment Legal Documentation

A. Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs)

Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs) are essential legal instruments that protect sensitive information exchanged between startup and potential investors during the pre-investment phase. These agreements establish a confidential relationship, legally obligating the parties to maintain the secrecy of any proprietary information shared during the due diligence process.

NDAs serve as a safeguard for startup, allowing them to disclose confidential information, such as financial data, business plans, and intellectual property, without fear of misappropriation. By having a well-drafted NDA in place, startup can engage in transparent discussions with potential investors while mitigating the risk of unauthorized disclosure or use of their trade secrets and proprietary information.

Protecting confidential information during due diligence

Due diligence is a critical stage in the investment process, where potential investors thoroughly examine a startup’s business model, financials, and legal aspects. During this phase, startup often need to share sensitive information to enable investors to make informed decisions. NDAs play a vital role in protecting this confidential information from being disclosed to third parties or used for any purpose other than evaluating the investment opportunity.

NDAs create a legal obligation for the receiving party (the investor) to maintain the confidentiality of the information shared by the disclosing party (the startup). This obligation extends to the investor’s employees, advisors, and any other individuals who may have access to the confidential information. By clearly defining the scope of confidential information and the responsibilities of the parties involved, NDAs provide startups with the necessary legal protection and peace of mind during the due diligence process.

Key clauses in NDAs for startup investments

To ensure the effectiveness of NDAs in protecting confidential information during startup investments, it is crucial to include certain key clauses. These clauses should be carefully drafted to address the specific needs and concerns of both the startup and the investor.

  1. Definition of confidential information: The NDA should clearly define the scope of information considered confidential. This may include financial data, business plans, product designs, customer lists, and any other sensitive information shared during the due diligence process.
  2. Obligations of the receiving party: The agreement should specify the responsibilities of the investor in maintaining the confidentiality of the information received. This includes not disclosing the information to third parties, using it only for the purpose of evaluating the investment opportunity, and implementing appropriate safeguards to prevent unauthorized access.
  3. Exceptions to confidentiality: NDAs should outline specific circumstances under which the confidentiality obligations may not apply. Common exceptions include information that is already public knowledge, independently developed by the receiving party, or required to be disclosed by law.
  4. Term and termination: The NDA should specify the duration of the confidentiality obligations and the conditions under which the agreement may be terminated. The term of the NDA should be long enough to protect the startup’s interests, even after the investment process concludes.
  5. Remedies for breach: The agreement should stipulate the consequences and legal remedies available to the startup in case of a breach of confidentiality by the investor. This may include injunctive relief, monetary damages, and the right to terminate the investment process.

By incorporating these key clauses, startup can ensure that their NDAs provide robust protection for their confidential information during the pre-investment stage. Well-drafted NDAs not only safeguard the startup’s proprietary information but also foster trust and confidence in the investment process, enabling startup to engage with potential investors more effectively.

B. Term Sheets

Purpose and key components of term sheets

Term sheets are crucial documents that outline the key terms and conditions of a proposed investment deal between a startup and potential investors. They serve as a blueprint for the investment, providing a framework for negotiations and setting the stage for the drafting of legally binding agreements.

The primary purpose of a term sheet is to ensure that all parties involved have a clear understanding of the essential aspects of the deal before proceeding with more detailed legal documentation. By outlining the key terms, term sheets help align expectations, identify potential deal-breakers early on, and streamline the negotiation process.

Some of the key components typically found in a term sheet include:

  1. Valuation: The pre-money and post-money valuation of the startup, which determines the company’s worth and the investor’s ownership stake.
  2. Investment amount and structure: The total amount of capital being invested and the type of securities being issued, such as equity shares or convertible notes.
  3. Liquidation preferences: The order in which investors and other shareholders are paid out in the event of a liquidation or exit.
  4. Voting rights and board composition: The decision-making powers granted to investors and the allocation of seats on the company’s board of directors.
  5. Anti-dilution provisions: Clauses that protect investors from the dilution of their ownership stake in the event of future financing rounds at lower valuations.
  6. Founder vesting and restrictions: Provisions that outline the vesting schedule for founder shares and any restrictions on their ability to sell or transfer shares.

By addressing these key components, term sheets provide a solid foundation for the investment process and help ensure that all parties are aligned before proceeding with the time-consuming and costly process of drafting definitive legal agreements.

Binding and non-binding provisions

One of the essential aspects of a term sheet is understanding which provisions are binding and which are non-binding. In most cases, term sheets are considered non-binding agreements, meaning that they do not create legally enforceable obligations for either party to complete the investment transaction.

However, certain specific clauses within a term sheet may be explicitly designated as binding, even if the overall document is non-binding. These binding provisions typically include:

  1. Confidentiality: A clause that requires all parties to maintain the confidentiality of the information shared during the negotiation process.
  2. Exclusivity (or “no-shop” provision): A clause that prohibits the startup from negotiating with other potential investors for a specified period, typically 30-60 days.
  3. Expenses: A provision that outlines how the costs associated with the transaction, such as legal and due diligence fees, will be allocated between the parties.
  4. Governing law and dispute resolution: Clauses that specify which jurisdiction’s laws will govern the agreement and how disputes will be resolved.

The binding nature of these specific provisions helps protect the interests of both the startup and the investors by ensuring that sensitive information remains confidential, preventing the startup from “shopping around” for better deals, and providing a framework for resolving potential disputes. It is crucial for startup and investors to carefully review the term sheet and understand which provisions are binding and which are non-binding.

C. Due Diligence Documentation

Legal due diligence checklist for startups

Legal due diligence is a critical aspect of the startup investment process, as it helps investors identify potential risks and liabilities associated with the target company. A comprehensive legal due diligence checklist for startup typically covers the following areas:

  1. Corporate records and charter documents
  • Certificate of incorporation, memorandum and articles of association
  • Shareholder agreements, voting agreements, and other relevant contracts
  • Board and shareholder meeting minutes, resolutions, and consents
  1. Intellectual property (IP) documentation
  • Patents, trademarks, copyrights, and other registered IP
  • IP assignment agreements, licenses, and royalty agreements
  • Confidentiality and non-disclosure agreements (NDAs)
  1. Employment and labour matters
  • Employment agreements, offer letters, and termination agreements
  • Employee stock option plans (ESOPs) and related documentation
  • Non-compete and non-solicitation agreements
  1. Material contracts and agreements
  • Customer and supplier contracts, leases, and service agreements
  • Loan and credit agreements, security interests, and guarantees
  • Joint venture, partnership, and collaboration agreements
  1. Litigation and regulatory compliance
  • Pending or threatened litigation, arbitration, or regulatory proceedings
  • Compliance with industry-specific regulations and licenses
  • Environmental, health, and safety compliance
  1. Tax matters
  • Income tax returns, tax payment receipts, and tax registration certificates
  • Compliance with tax laws and regulations, including withholding tax and indirect taxes
  • Transfer pricing documentation and agreements

Conducting a thorough legal due diligence helps startups identify and address any potential legal issues, ensuring a smoother investment process and mitigating future risks.

Intellectual property (IP) documentation and protection

Intellectual property is often a startup’s most valuable asset, making IP documentation and protection a crucial aspect of due diligence. Investors will closely examine a startup’s IP portfolio to assess its value, enforceability, and potential risks. Key areas of focus include:

  1. IP ownership and chain of title
  • IP assignment agreements from founders, employees, and contractors
  • IP transfer agreements related to mergers, acquisitions, or spin-offs
  • Confirmation of proper recording and registration of IP rights
  1. Patents
  • Patent applications, granted patents, and patent search reports
  • Freedom-to-operate (FTO) analyses and non-infringement opinions
  • Patent maintenance and annuity payment records
  1. Trademarks and copyrights
  • Trademark applications, registrations, and search reports
  • Copyright registrations and documentation of authorship
  • Domain name registrations and social media account ownership
  1. Trade secrets and confidential information
  • NDAs with employees, contractors, and third parties
  • Trade secret policies, procedures, and protective measures
  • Documentation of trade secret development and maintenance
  1. IP disputes and litigation
  • Past or ongoing IP infringement claims, oppositions, or invalidation proceedings
  • Settlement agreements, licenses, and coexistence agreements
  • IP-related indemnification obligations or warranties

Startups should maintain well-organized and comprehensive IP documentation to demonstrate the strength and value of their IP portfolio to potential investors.

Read our guide on due diligence for startups for more.

III. Investment Agreements

A. Share Subscription Agreement

Key terms and conditions for share subscription

A Share Subscription Agreement (SSA) is a legally binding contract between a startup and an investor, outlining the terms and conditions under which the investor will subscribe to the startup’s shares. The SSA is a crucial document that establishes the rights and obligations of both parties and sets the foundation for the investment relationship.

Key terms and conditions typically covered in an SSA include:

  1. Subscription price: The price per share at which the investor will subscribe to the startup’s shares, based on the agreed-upon valuation.
  2. Number of shares: The total number of shares being issued to the investor, which determines their ownership stake in the company.
  3. Payment terms: The schedule and method of payment for the subscribed shares, including any tranches or milestones.
  4. Conditions precedent: Any specific conditions that must be fulfilled before the investment is completed, such as regulatory approvals or due diligence requirements.
  5. Use of proceeds: A clause specifying how the startup will use the funds raised from the investment, often linked to the company’s growth and development plans.
  6. Representation & Warranties: The stakeholders make express statements about their legal standing, authority to enter into the agreement, and the accuracy of information provided. These include warranties related to the startup’s intellectual property, financial statements, and compliance with applicable laws and regulations.

Representations and warranties by the startup

Representations and warranties are statements made by the startup to the investor, assuring them of certain facts and circumstances related to the company. These clauses are critical for establishing trust and transparency between the parties and help the investor make an informed decision.

Common representations and warranties in an SSA include:

  1. Corporate existence and authority: The startup confirms that it is duly incorporated, validly existing, and has the necessary authority to enter into the agreement.
  2. Capitalization and ownership: The startup provides details of its current share capital structure and confirms that the shares being issued are free from any encumbrances.
  3. Financial statements: The startup warrants that its financial statements are accurate, complete, and prepared in accordance with applicable accounting standards.
  4. Intellectual property: The startup represents that it owns or has the right to use all intellectual property necessary for its business and that there are no infringement claims against it.
  5. Compliance with laws: The startup confirms that it is in compliance with all applicable laws, regulations, and licenses related to its business.

Accurate and comprehensive representations and warranties help mitigate the investor’s risk and provide them with legal recourse in case of any misrepresentations or breaches by the startup.

B. Shareholders’ Agreement

Rights and obligations of shareholders

A Shareholders’ Agreement (SHA) is a contract between the startup’s shareholders, including the founders, investors, and other key stakeholders. The SHA defines the rights and obligations of each shareholder and establishes the framework for the company’s governance and management.

Key rights and obligations covered in an SHA include:

  1. Voting rights: The SHA outlines the voting rights attached to each class of shares and the matters that require shareholder approval.
  2. Information rights: Investors often require access to the startup’s financial and operational information, which is stipulated in the SHA.
  3. Transfer restrictions: The SHA may include provisions that restrict the transfer of shares, such as right of first refusal, tag-along, or drag-along rights.
  4. Pre-emptive rights: These rights give existing shareholders the opportunity to maintain their ownership percentage by participating in future funding rounds.
  5. Anti-dilution: Provisions that protect investors from the dilution of their ownership stake in the event of future financing rounds at lower valuations.
  6. Liquidation preferences: The SHA defines the order in which shareholders are paid out in the event of a liquidation or exit, often giving investors preferential treatment.
  7. Affirmative Vote Matters: Certain strategic decisions may require the approval of a specific majority of the board or shareholders, as defined in the SHA.
  8. Promoter Shares Lock-in: Restrictions on the transfer or sale of shares held by the promoters (founders) for a specified period to ensure their continued commitment to the company.
  9. Treatment of Promoter Shares: Provisions governing the rights and obligations attached to shares held by the promoters, such as vesting schedules, transfer restrictions, and tag-along rights.

Governance structure and board composition

The SHA also establishes the startup’s governance structure and the composition of its board of directors. This is crucial for ensuring that the company is managed effectively and that the interests of all shareholders are protected.

Key aspects of governance and board composition in an SHA include:

  1. Board size and composition: The SHA specifies the number of directors on the board and the allocation of board seats among the shareholders.
  2. Appointment and removal of directors: The agreement outlines the procedures for appointing and removing directors, including any specific rights granted to investors.
  3. Board meetings and quorum: The SHA sets out the frequency of board meetings and the quorum required for making decisions.
  4. Reserved matters: Certain strategic decisions may require the approval of a specific majority of the board or shareholders, as defined in the SHA.
  5. Committees: The SHA may provide for the establishment of specific committees, such as an audit committee or compensation committee, to assist in the company’s governance.

A well-drafted SHA ensures that the startup’s governance structure is transparent, efficient, and aligned with the interests of all shareholders. It helps prevent potential conflicts and provides a framework for resolving disputes, ultimately contributing to the company’s long-term success.

C. Share Purchase Agreement

Terms for secondary share transactions

A Share Purchase Agreement (SPA) is a legal contract that governs the sale and purchase of shares between shareholders, typically in a secondary transaction. Secondary transactions involve the transfer of existing shares from one shareholder to another, as opposed to the issuance of new shares by the company.

Key terms covered in an SPA for secondary share transactions include:

  1. Parties to the agreement: The SPA identifies the seller(s) and buyer(s) of the shares, along with their respective rights and obligations.
  2. Number and class of shares: The agreement specifies the number and class of shares being transferred, along with any associated rights or preferences.
  3. Purchase price and payment terms: The SPA sets out the price per share and the total consideration for the transaction, as well as the payment schedule and method.
  4. Representations and warranties: The seller makes certain representations and warranties regarding their ownership of the shares and the absence of any encumbrances or third-party claims.
  5. Indemnification: The SPA may include indemnification clauses that protect the buyer from any losses or liabilities arising from the seller’s breach of representations or warranties.

Conditions precedent and closing mechanics

An SPA also outlines the conditions that must be satisfied before the transaction can be completed (conditions precedent) and the mechanics of the closing process.

Common conditions precedent and closing mechanics in an SPA include:

  1. Due diligence: The buyer may have the right to conduct due diligence on the company and the shares being transferred, with the transaction conditional upon satisfactory findings.
  2. Regulatory approvals: The SPA may require the parties to obtain necessary regulatory approvals, such as from the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) or the Reserve Bank of India (RBI).
  3. Third-party consents: If the transfer of shares requires the consent of any third parties, such as lenders or other shareholders, the SPA will make the transaction conditional upon obtaining such consents.
  4. Closing deliverables: The SPA specifies the documents and actions required from each party at the closing, such as the transfer of share certificates, payment of consideration, and execution of any ancillary agreements.
  5. Post-closing obligations: The agreement may include certain post-closing obligations, such as the seller’s non-compete or non-solicitation undertakings, or the buyer’s obligation to provide indemnification.

A carefully drafted SPA ensures that the terms of the secondary share transaction are clearly defined and that the interests of both the seller and the buyer are protected. It helps minimize the risk of disputes and provides a roadmap for the smooth execution of the transaction.

IV. Post-Investment Legal Documentation

A. Amended Articles of Association

Reflecting rights of investors in the company’s constitution

The Articles of Association (AoA) serve as the constitution of a company, outlining the rules and regulations for its internal management and governance. Following an investment, it is crucial to amend the AoA to reflect the rights and obligations of the new investors, ensuring alignment with the terms of the investment agreements.

Key investor rights that should be incorporated into the amended AoA include:

  1. Voting rights: The amended AoA should specify the voting rights attached to the shares issued to the investors, including any preferential or differential voting rights.
  2. Board representation: If the investors have been granted the right to nominate directors to the company’s board, the amended AoA should outline the procedure for their appointment and removal.
  3. Information and inspection rights: The AoA should reflect the investors’ right to receive financial and operational information about the company and to inspect its books and records.
  4. Pre-emptive rights: If the investors have been granted pre-emptive rights to participate in future funding rounds, the amended AoA should clearly state these rights and the procedure for their exercise.
  5. Transfer restrictions: The AoA should incorporate any restrictions on the transfer of shares, such as right of first refusal, tag-along, or drag-along rights, as agreed upon in the investment agreements.

Aligning with provisions of investment agreements

The amended AoA must be carefully drafted to ensure consistency with the terms of the investment agreements, such as the Shareholders’ Agreement and the Share Subscription Agreement. Any discrepancies between these documents could lead to disputes and legal challenges.

In case of any conflict between the provisions of the AoA and the investment agreements, the AoA generally prevails, as it is a public document and is binding on all shareholders. Therefore, it is essential to harmonize the terms of the investment agreements with the amended AoA to avoid potential conflicts.

The process of amending the AoA typically involves:

  1. Board resolution: The board of directors must pass a resolution approving the proposed amendments to the AoA.
  2. Shareholder approval: The amendments must be approved by a special resolution of the shareholders, requiring a 75% majority (or as specified in the existing AoA).
  3. Filing with the Registrar of Companies (RoC): The amended AoA, along with the requisite forms and fees, must be filed with the RoC within 15 days of the passing of the special resolution.

B. Board and Shareholder Resolutions

Approving investment and related matters

Board and shareholder resolutions are essential for approving various aspects of the investment process and ensuring compliance with legal requirements.

Board resolutions are required for matters such as:

  1. Allotment of shares: The board must pass a resolution allotting shares to the investors in accordance with the terms of the investment agreements.
  2. Appointment of investor nominee directors: If the investors have the right to nominate directors, the board must pass a resolution appointing them to the board.
  3. Convening a general meeting: The board must pass a resolution to convene a general meeting of shareholders to approve the investment and related matters.

Shareholder resolutions are necessary for approving critical aspects of the investment, such as:

  1. Issuance of shares: Shareholders must pass an ordinary resolution (or a special resolution, if required by the AoA) approving the issuance of shares to the investors.
  2. Adoption of amended AoA: Shareholders must pass a special resolution adopting the amended AoA that reflects the rights of the investors.
  3. Appointment of investor nominee directors: Shareholders may need to pass an ordinary resolution appointing the investor nominee directors, if required by the AoA.

These board and shareholder resolutions must be properly drafted, clearly stating the decisions taken and the authority under which they are passed. The resolutions must be filed with the RoC within 30 days of being passed, using the prescribed forms such as MGT-14.

Failure to pass the necessary resolutions or to file them with the RoC within the stipulated time can result in penalties and legal consequences for the company and its officers. Therefore, it is crucial to ensure that all requisite board and shareholder resolutions are passed and filed in a timely manner to ensure compliance and to give legal effect to the investment transaction.

C. Regulatory Filings

Form PAS-3 for allotment of shares

Form PAS-3 is a mandatory filing required under Sections 39(4) and 42(9) of the Companies Act, 2013, read with Rules 12 and 14 of the Companies (Prospectus and Allotment of Securities) Rules, 2014. Whenever a company makes an allotment of shares or securities, it must file a return of allotment with the Registrar of Companies (ROC) in Form PAS-3.

The due date for filing Form PAS-3 depends on the manner of allotment:

  • For allotment of shares to the public at large: Within 30 days of allotment
  • For allotment of shares through private placement: Within 15 days of allotment

Form PAS-3 requires the following key information:

  1. Details of the allotment, including the number and class of shares or securities allotted
  2. Allotment price and amount paid on each share or security
  3. Details of the allottees, including their names, addresses, and number of shares or securities allotted to each
  4. Particulars of any bonus shares issued, if applicable
  5. Details of any private placement made, if applicable
  6. Company’s updated capital structure post-allotment

The filing fee for Form PAS-3 is based on the company’s authorized share capital, ranging from INR 200 to INR 600. Additional fees are applicable for delayed filings, with the quantum of additional fees increasing based on the extent of delay.

Non-filing or delayed filing of Form PAS-3 can attract penalties for the company and its officers in default. Therefore, it is crucial for companies to ensure timely compliance with this regulatory requirement after any allotment of shares or securities.

Form MGT-14 for special resolutions

Form MGT-14 is required to be filed under Sections 94(1) and 117(1) of the Companies Act, 2013, for registering certain resolutions and agreements with the ROC. This form is typically filed after the passing of special resolutions or other resolutions specified in Section 117(3) of the Act.

Some key special resolutions that require filing of Form MGT-14 include:

  1. Alteration of memorandum or articles of association
  2. Change in registered office address
  3. Approval for the issue of securities through private placement
  4. Variation of shareholders’ rights
  5. Reduction of share capital
  6. Approval for buy-back of securities
  7. Approval for voluntary winding up of the company

Form MGT-14 must be filed within 30 days of passing the special resolution, along with a certified true copy of the resolution and explanatory statement. The filing fee for Form MGT-14 ranges from INR 200 to INR 600, based on the company’s authorized share capital.

Non-compliance with the requirement to file Form MGT-14 can result in significant penalties for the company and its officers. The company may be liable to pay a fine of INR 1 lakh to INR 25 lakh, while officers in default may face a fine of INR 50,000 to INR 5 lakh.

Given the severe consequences of non-compliance, companies must ensure that all necessary special resolutions are filed with the ROC through Form MGT-14 within the prescribed time limit.

Form DIR-12 for appointment of investor nominee directors

Form DIR-12 is required to be filed under Section 170 of the Companies Act, 2013, read with Rule 17 of the Companies (Appointment and Qualification of Directors) Rules, 2014, for intimating the ROC about the appointment of directors, including investor nominee directors.

When a company appoints an investor nominee director pursuant to an investment agreement, it must file Form DIR-12 with the ROC within 30 days of the appointment. The form requires the following key details:

  1. Particulars of the appointee, including name, DIN (Director Identification Number), PAN, and residential address
  2. Date of appointment and term of office
  3. Details of the nominating investor or institution
  4. Certified true copy of the board resolution approving the appointment
  5. Consent to act as a director in Form DIR-2
  6. Declaration by the appointee in Form DIR-8 regarding eligibility and compliance with legal requirements

The filing fee for Form DIR-12 is INR 500 for companies with authorized share capital up to INR 10 lakh and INR 1,000 for companies with authorized share capital above INR 10 lakh.

Failure to file Form DIR-12 within the prescribed time can result in a penalty of INR 50,000 to INR 5 lakh for the company and INR 50,000 to INR 1 lakh for the officers in default.

Companies must ensure timely compliance with the requirement to file Form DIR-12 whenever an investor nominee director is appointed to the board. This filing helps maintain transparency in corporate governance and keeps the ROC informed about changes in the company’s management structure.

V. Exit Documentation

A. Share Transfer Forms

Effecting transfer of shares during exit events

Share transfer forms play a crucial role in facilitating the transfer of shares during exit events, such as a sale of the company or a shareholder’s departure. These forms, also known as stock transfer forms or instruments of transfer, document the details of the share transfer, including the parties involved, the number and class of shares being transferred, and the consideration paid.

When a shareholder decides to sell their shares, they must complete a share transfer form and obtain the approval of the company’s directors. The directors must ensure that the transfer complies with any restrictions or conditions set out in the company’s articles of association or shareholders’ agreement. Once the transfer is approved, the share transfer form is executed, and the company’s register of members is updated to reflect the new ownership structure.

In the context of an exit event, such as a company sale or a buyout of a shareholder’s stake, share transfer forms are essential for efficiently transferring ownership to the acquiring party. The forms should be prepared in advance, with all relevant details included, to minimize delays and ensure a smooth transition of ownership.

Adherence to transfer restrictions in shareholders’ agreement

Shareholders’ agreements often contain provisions that restrict the transfer of shares, such as right of first refusal, tag-along rights, or drag-along rights. These restrictions are designed to protect the interests of the existing shareholders and maintain control over the company’s ownership structure.

When executing share transfer forms during an exit event, it is crucial to ensure that the transfer adheres to any applicable restrictions outlined in the shareholders’ agreement. Failure to comply with these restrictions could result in the transfer being deemed invalid or lead to legal disputes among the shareholders.

For example, if the shareholders’ agreement includes a right of first refusal, the selling shareholder must first offer their shares to the existing shareholders before transferring them to a third party. The share transfer form should reflect this process and provide evidence that the right of first refusal has been respected.

Similarly, if the shareholders’ agreement contains tag-along or drag-along rights, the share transfer forms must be structured to accommodate these provisions. This may involve coordinating the transfer of shares from multiple shareholders simultaneously or ensuring that the terms of the transfer are consistent with the requirements set out in the shareholders’ agreement.

B. Drag-Along and Tag-Along Notices

Exercising drag-along and tag-along rights

Drag-along and tag-along rights are common provisions in shareholders’ agreements that come into play during exit events. Drag-along rights allow majority shareholders to force minority shareholders to sell their shares alongside them to a third-party purchaser, ensuring a complete exit for the majority shareholders. Conversely, tag-along rights enable minority shareholders to participate in a sale of shares by the majority shareholders on the same terms and conditions.

To exercise drag-along rights, the majority shareholders must issue a drag-along notice to the minority shareholders. This notice informs the minority shareholders of the proposed sale and requires them to sell their shares to the third-party purchaser on the same terms as the majority shareholders. The notice should include details such as the identity of the purchaser, the price per share, and the timeline for completing the transaction.

Similarly, when minority shareholders wish to exercise their tag-along rights, they must issue a tag-along notice to the majority shareholders. This notice communicates the minority shareholders’ intention to participate in the sale and requires the majority shareholders to ensure that the third-party purchaser extends the offer to include the minority shareholders’ shares on the same terms.

Timelines and procedures for issuing notices

Shareholders’ agreements typically specify the timelines and procedures for issuing drag-along and tag-along notices. These provisions ensure that all parties have sufficient time to review the proposed transaction and make informed decisions.

For drag-along notices, the shareholders’ agreement may stipulate a minimum notice period, such as 30 or 60 days, before the proposed sale date. This allows the minority shareholders to assess the terms of the sale and seek legal or financial advice if necessary. The agreement may also outline the specific information that must be included in the drag-along notice, such as the purchase price, payment terms, and any conditions precedent to the sale.

Similarly, for tag-along notices, the shareholders’ agreement may specify a time frame within which minority shareholders must notify the majority shareholders of their intention to participate in the sale. This ensures that the majority shareholders can coordinate the sale process effectively and avoid delays.

Adhering to the timelines and procedures set out in the shareholders’ agreement is crucial for ensuring the validity of the drag-along or tag-along process and minimizing the risk of legal challenges.

C. Deed of Adherence

Binding new shareholders to existing agreements

A deed of adherence, also known as a deed of accession, is a legal document that binds new shareholders to the terms of an existing shareholders’ agreement. When a company issues new shares or existing shareholders transfer their shares to a third party, the new shareholders must agree to be bound by the rights and obligations set out in the shareholders’ agreement.

By executing a deed of adherence, the new shareholders formally acknowledge and accept the terms of the shareholders’ agreement, including any transfer restrictions, voting rights, and exit provisions. This ensures that all shareholders, both existing and new, are subject to the same rules and obligations, maintaining the integrity of the agreement.

The deed of adherence typically includes clauses stating that the new shareholder:

  1. Has received a copy of the shareholders’ agreement and agrees to be bound by its terms;
  2. Will be entitled to the same rights and benefits as the existing shareholders under the agreement; and
  3. Will be subject to the same obligations and restrictions as the existing shareholders.

Ensuring continuity of rights and obligations

Executing a deed of adherence is essential for ensuring the continuity of rights and obligations among shareholders, particularly during exit events or when new investors join the company.

Without a deed of adherence, new shareholders may not be bound by the terms of the existing shareholders’ agreement, potentially leading to inconsistencies in the rights and obligations of different shareholders. This could create complications during exit events, such as disputes over the application of drag-along or tag-along rights, or disagreements regarding the valuation of shares.

By requiring new shareholders to execute a deed of adherence, the company can maintain a uniform set of rules and expectations for all shareholders, reducing the risk of conflicts and facilitating smoother exit processes. The deed of adherence ensures that the rights and obligations outlined in the shareholders’ agreement, such as transfer restrictions, voting provisions, and exit mechanisms, remain enforceable and consistent over time, even as the composition of the shareholder group changes.

The deed of adherence is a crucial document in the context of exit documentation, as it ensures that new shareholders are properly integrated into the existing legal framework and that the rights and obligations of all shareholders remain aligned throughout the life of the company, including during exit events.

VI. Final Words

Comprehensive and well-drafted legal documentation is essential for mitigating risks and fostering the growth of startup in India. By establishing clear rights, obligations, and expectations for all parties involved, robust legal documentation helps to minimize the potential for disputes, protect the interests of investors and founders, and provide a stable foundation for the startup’s operations and growth.

For investors, comprehensive legal documentation serves as a critical risk management tool, ensuring that their investment is secure and that they have adequate protections in place. By conducting thorough due diligence, negotiating favourable terms, and ensuring that all agreements are properly executed and complied with, investors can reduce their exposure to legal and financial risks and increase the likelihood of a successful investment outcome.

For startup, having a strong legal framework in place can be a significant advantage in attracting investment and achieving growth. Startup that demonstrates a commitment to legal compliance, good governance, and the protection of investor rights are more likely to secure funding from reputable investors and benefit from their expertise and networks. Additionally, a well-documented legal structure can help startup to manage their operations more effectively, make informed decisions, and avoid costly legal pitfalls as they scale.

The framework of legal documentation for investors in India is a critical aspect of the startup ecosystem, providing the necessary structure and protections to facilitate investment, mitigate risks, and support the growth of innovative companies. By understanding and adhering to the key legal considerations at each stage of the investment process, investors and startups can equip themselves better towards understanding the complexities of the investment ecosystem and build successful, long-term partnerships that drive innovation, create value, and contribute to the overall growth of the Indian economy.


leave a comment